The world of digital currencies is vast and often overwhelming, with thousands of projects claiming to be the next breakthrough in finance, money, and technology. This naturally raises several important questions: Could Bitcoin be surpassed by a superior cryptocurrency? Is Bitcoin outdated compared to newer blockchain-based projects? Does “blockchain technology” have applications beyond money? And why has Bitcoin maintained its dominance despite countless competitors? These are common concerns for those new to Bitcoin and the broader digital currency space.
This series will make the case that Bitcoin stands alone as the only truly decentralized, highly secure monetary protocol with absolute digital scarcity, unparalleled settlement assurance, and an unchanging, neutral, and ethical monetary policy. These qualities are not incidental but fundamental to Bitcoin’s design, which distinguishes it from the rest of the cryptocurrency landscape. Bitcoin achieves decentralized, politically neutral consensus on a global scale without relying on trusted third parties. This means participants can verify ownership and transfer value without the need for banks, governments, or centralized authorities to mediate transactions. Bitcoin isn’t just another payments app. it’s a neutral, global monetary protocol that serves as the foundation for a more transparent and just monetary system.
The distinction between Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies has been explored in many essays and discussions, but this series will take a structured approach to breaking down what truly separates Bitcoin from the rest. We will organize the key issues into three broad categories: economic, technical, and ethical. This framework will provide a systematic examination of the flaws inherent to alternative cryptocurrencies and the qualities that make Bitcoin fundamentally different. While there is some overlap among these issues, this structure will help readers navigate the many misconceptions surrounding digital currencies.
Beyond these distinctions, we will also examine Bitcoin Maximalism. This philosophy is often criticized as rigid or even “toxic.” However, we argue that Bitcoin Maximalism is not only justified but necessary. In our humble and informed view, it represents the only viable path away from the Riba-based monetary system and toward a financial future built on sound, incorruptible money.
This series will challenge conventional narratives and provide clarity for those seeking to understand why Bitcoin is not just another cryptocurrency, but the only one that truly matters. Throughout this series, the term “crypto” will refer to the broader cryptocurrency landscape, excluding Bitcoin. With that distinction in mind, let’s begin by examining the economic issues that plague the crypto industry.
Economic Issues of Crypto
There are many ways to design a monetary policy for digital cash. Should it have a fixed supply or an expanding one? Who determines the token supply, and how do you reward participants for securing the network and following consensus rules?
When it comes to Bitcoin, these questions are straightforward. Bitcoin’s supply is fixed at 21 million, with a predictable issuance rate that decreases over time. This gradual reduction in rewards, known as the halving, ensures that miners receive diminishing subsidies until the final fraction of Bitcoin is mined, after which they’ll be paid entirely by fees. The difficulty adjustment mechanism keeps issuance on track and rooted in time so that blocks are not added too quickly or too slowly, until the cap is reached.
For cryptocurrencies, however, these questions are far more complicated. While some projects may claim to have a fixed supply and proof-of-work-based issuance, the key difference lies in credibility. Parker Lewis explains the difference between a “blockchain” with a fixed supply versus the actual fixed supply of Bitcoin:
“Recognize that there is nothing about a software application or a “blockchain” that guarantees a fixed supply, and bitcoin’s supply schedule is not credible because software dictates it. Instead, 21 million is only credible because it is governed on a decentralized basis and by an ever-increasing number of network participants. The more decentralized bitcoin becomes, the more secure it is. As more individuals participate in consensus, 21 million becomes a more credibly fixed number. Similarly, bitcoin becomes a more reliable constant as each individual controls a smaller and smaller share over time. As adoption increases, security and utility work in lockstep. Consider the distribution and relative density of bitcoin adoption worldwide. As reach and density within each market spread, bitcoin’s constant hardens and becomes harder to change.”
Lewis, Parker A. Gradually, Then Suddenly: A Framework for Understanding Bitcoin as Money. 2023. p. 43.
Therefore, Bitcoin’s supply isn’t just fixed, it’s credibly enforced. Though only Allah (swt) knows the future, we can reasonably expect Bitcoin’s monetary policy to remain unchanged for decades, even centuries. Attempts to alter Bitcoin’s rules, such as the controversial effort to increase block size, have resulted in hard forks that failed to gain consensus. Changing Bitcoin’s monetary policy, especially the fixed issuance rate, would be far more difficult, if not impossible, and would result in the same outcome of a hardforked network with barely any users. In short, this credibility is an emergent property of Bitcoin’s decentralized and distributed consensus, not a promise from a development team or any marketing agency.
In contrast, most cryptocurrencies follow not only different monetary policies but ones that frequently change. These shifts are often dictated by “community” votes, influential insiders, or core development teams. While adaptability may appear like a strength since it seemingly allows projects to respond quickly to user demands, this flexibility mirrors the instability of fiat systems, where interest rates and monetary supply fluctuate in cycles of expansion and contraction, which forces markets to react to unpredictable changes.
Credibly enforcing a monetary policy within the crypto space is nearly impossible, as most projects sacrifice some level of decentralization for other utilities or features. We’ll explore these trade-offs further in the next section, but the result is clear: without decentralization, these projects lack the ability to enforce a stable monetary policy. Even if a majority of users were involved in shaping a project’s token economics, or “tokenomics”, holding such a token as a store of value becomes risky. If the supply can be diluted at any moment, potentially without warning, it undermines confidence in the currency’s long-term value.
So the choice is clear: when presented with the option between a currency with a credibly fixed supply and one with an unpredictable and malleable policy, people will gravitate toward the former. Bitcoin’s predictable scarcity offers a level of certainty that no cryptocurrency with a changeable policy can match.
Another glaring economic issue with crypto is that if they want to compete with bitcoin, then they have to offer something that the Bitcoin timechain doesn’t offer. At first glance, this might seem reasonable, as no system is perfect, and improvements are always possible. Many cryptocurrencies advertise features like faster confirmations, smart contracts, NFTs, and DeFi applications and such. Yet, despite these seemingly impressive utilities, none of these projects come close to matching Bitcoin’s massive liquidity or global volume. Why is that?
The key issue lies in how these crypto projects position themselves. Nearly every altcoin markets a utility that Bitcoin doesn’t provide, but these utilities are generally non-monetary. Their strategy to compete with Bitcoin, the soundest form of digital money, is by offering functionalities unrelated to money. The flaw here should be obvious: competing with Bitcoin through non-monetary utility is an implicit admission that they can’t rival Bitcoin as money.
It’s like trying to market aluminum as a superior alternative to gold. While aluminum may offer unique practical uses that gold doesn’t, it’s vastly inferior as money. Gold’s monetary properties make it the preferred store of value, while aluminum can’t compete in that space, no matter its non-monetary benefits. Similarly, altcoins might provide niche utilities, but they fall short as monetary assets.
Even if we assume Bitcoin lacks a certain feature needed to function as money, the challenge remains: which cryptocurrency would Bitcoin users adopt instead? Thousands of altcoins claim to offer unique utilities. For one to replace Bitcoin, it would need to attract a critical mass of users to establish network effects. However, the competition within the altcoin space makes this nearly impossible. No single cryptocurrency can replicate Bitcoin’s level of security, decentralization, and immutability while simultaneously offering some utility Bitcoin users can’t do without. Moreover, many of these financial and non-monetary utilities can be built on Bitcoin’s higher layers without altering its base protocol.
This leads to another economic flaw: there’s no compelling reason to hold an altcoin for longer than needed to access its utility. Take NFTs as an example. If the purpose of a token is to mint an NFT, why would anyone hold that token beyond the moment it’s used? This reveals a deeper economic problem. Without a reason to store value in the token, users have no incentive to hold it longer than absolutely necessary. If a utility is the sole reason for holding a token, it becomes a transactional tool rather than a store of value, and it will never be able to actually monetize.
Allen Farrington and Anders Larson talk about this irreconcilable economic issue as there’s no monetary motivation for holding the token since all these attempts of digital cash fight for liquidity:
“Why would a non-monetary token need to have a nonzero holding period and hence a non-negligible value in the first place? In short, why would anybody hold something that is money, but only for X, for any period longer than the nanosecond required to transact it? It’s analogous to the choice between dollar bills and casino chips of the same denomination. Why willingly take on the casino’s liabilities and restrict the ability to engage in any other commerce? Why not buy casino chips only when you go to the casino?This isn’t a death knell in and of itself, but note that it relies on a far more delicate consensus than an asset straightforwardly trying to be money and nothing more. If you can’t rely on others holding it (because it’s money and nobody needs a particular reason to hold money), then sustaining its value very likely requires some form of coordination. Worse still, whatever coordination is achieved likely lacks inherent economic incentives that independently motivate it (besides the attempt to derive benefit from the coordination itself). Additionally, it must overcome the economic disincentive to simply hold money instead. In other words, everything fights for liquidity.”
Farrington, Allen. Larson, Anders. Only the Strong Survive. 2021. Accessible at: https://www.uncerto.com/only-the-strong-survive
Ultimately, cryptocurrencies lost the competition with Bitcoin before the battle even began, as they operate from a flawed premise. They aren’t seriously competing as money; they’re trying to bootstrap some utility with their own token, only to vastly underperform against Bitcoin in fiat terms. This is one of the main reasons why bitcoin is so far ahead compared to any other cryptocurrency. It’s because they compete in a non-monetary way when they really should be attempting to compete as money, but crypto enthusiasts, whether they are aware of this fact or not, know that they cannot win this fight, and so Bitcoin will always remain at the top.
But hold on, there is actually one very good reason why some investors might hold onto certain cryptocurrencies for extended periods, and this concerns the promise of the “utility” of yield. The idea is that, unlike Bitcoin, these crypto tokens allow holders to earn a return directly through the blockchain layer. By “locking up” their tokens, investors can earn yield, which in many crypto systems is also presented as a way to secure the network without energy-intensive methods. This approach basically underlies the concept of proof-of-stake.
Proof-of-stake is a consensus algorithm used by many cryptocurrencies as an alternative to the energy-demanding proof-of-work model. Essentially, proof-of-stake allows network participants, called validators, to lock up a set amount of the native cryptocurrency as “stake,” granting them the ability to propose and validate new blocks. Validators receive block rewards and voting power proportional to their stake size, which is intended to incentivize honest participation while securing the network. However, as we’ll cover in the next section on technical issues, this setup inherently centralizes power among wealthier participants.
Today, earning yield has become the primary use case for many cryptocurrencies, making them seem attractive relative to Bitcoin. Yet here lies a deeper issue that we cannot stress enough: relying on yield as the central appeal of a cryptocurrency is not a substitute for monetary utility. In crypto, yield generation becomes the fundamental reason to hold these tokens. This reveals an implicit concession that they are competing as yield-producing assets, not as money.
In fact, when the main purpose of an asset is to generate yield, it starts resembling a financial security rather than a currency. In financial terms, a security is a tradable asset, like stocks, bonds, or derivatives, that represents ownership or creditor relationships and is subject to regulation. From this perspective, yield-generating cryptocurrencies align more with the characteristics of a security than with those of sound money.
Let’s take this issue of yield-generating cryptos a step further and ask the burning question: Where does all this yield even come from? In traditional scenarios, it’s obvious. A farmer’s yield comes from the harvest, and a business earns yield from its profits after covering costs. So yield, in its true sense, is a return generated from economically productive assets above their maintenance or depreciation.
So, what exactly is the “yield” being harvested in crypto? To be blunt, there are no productive assets at play here; crypto yields aren’t based on any real economic activity. Crypto advocates often claim that the yield is a reward for staking tokens to secure the network, likening it to proof-of-work but without the pesky energy requirement. We find this argument to be the height of ignorance and arrogance: ignorance for overlooking the lack of real financial backing, and arrogance for pretending that yield generation here is anything remotely comparable to proof-of-work.
When we say crypto yield isn’t real finance, we mean there’s no productive asset generating a return, yet it’s even worse than that. The main use case for non-proof-of-work tokens is to stake them, earn more of the same tokens, and re-stake those for even more tokens. This circular setup should raise eyebrows about its sustainability. Additionally, another troubling layer in the crypto ecosystem is the rampant rehypothecation and leverage of assets across various blockchain protocols, creating synthetic layers of value increasingly detached from the original collateral.
These practices, reminiscent of Riba money and fractional reserve banking, allow the same assets to be repeatedly reused in opaque ways to generate debt. This gives the illusion of overcollateralization while making the system extremely vulnerable to collapse if asset values drop. With no real economic backing or lender of last resort, this creates a fragile system dependent on an endless cycle of staking digital tokens. Lyn Alden captures this circularity brilliantly in her analysis of Ethereum, currently the largest proof-of-stake cryptocurrency:
“One of my concerns, when reviewing the biggest use cases for decentralized apps, is that a lot of the use-case is circular and speculative.
Ethereum is heavily used for decentralized exchanges of crypto tokens, crypto stablecoins that serve as liquid units of account for trading crypto tokens, and lending and earning interest on crypto tokens which is a practice that serves as a liquidity/borrowing source for traders of crypto tokens. To a lesser extent, it is also used for gamified ways to earn or trade various crypto tokens.
So, it’s a big operating system powered by crypto tokens, for the purpose of moving around… crypto tokens.
A healthy banking system in the real world would consist of people depositing money, and the banks making various loans for mortgages and for business financing, to generate real-world utility.
A speculation-based banking system, on the other hand, would consist of a bunch of banks taking deposit money, and then lending to speculators in the nearby stock market, along with technology providers that make this easier, and then what those speculators are trading mostly consists of shares of those banks, shares of those tech companies, and shares of the stock exchange, resulting in a big circular speculative party. The biggest use case so far for Ethereum is a decentralized version of that circular speculation-based system.”
Alden, Lyn. An Economic Analysis of Ethereum. 2021. Accessible at: https://www.lynalden.com/ethereum-analysis/
But as we’ll see in the next essay, the nature of cryptocurrencies like Ethereum are not even decentralized, so we contend that it’s practically the same structure of the current fractional reserve banking system.
So we still need to answer the question of where the yields are actually coming from and how they are sustained. It turns out that the answer is actually quite simple. For these yield-generating tokens to keep paying out, the monetary policy behind them requires an ever-expanding supply to support those yields. This brings us back to the core economic flaw mentioned at the beginning. Despite claiming scarcity, these cryptocurrencies lack it in any credible form. This is the fundamental difference from Bitcoin, which is credibly and absolutely scarce, with a truly fixed supply. In contrast, yield-producing tokens will likely face continuous shifts in monetary policy to meet stakers’ demands, with these changes almost certainly dictated by the project’s founders. Today, we see these projects release lofty, convoluted roadmaps, and updates that bear an uncanny resemblance to the Federal Reserve’s policy minutes. This yield-chasing high time preference behavior mimics the very fiat system many crypto projects claim to disrupt.
These economic flaws reveal a deeper truth, and it’s that these tokens aren’t even trying to function as money. If the primary goal is yield generation, then why reinvent the wheel with a new token? Fiat money already plays that role just fine, and it even incentivizes yield-seeking behavior. Because these cryptocurrencies aren’t optimized to be money, they don’t really qualify as money. They function more like securities than commodities, raising the question: why not just denominate these non-monetary utilities in fiat if it’s all about yield? The underlying issue is clear, and it’s that these tokens aren’t designed to be digital cash. They prioritize non-monetary functions, often at the cost of decentralization, which is why they can not truly compete with Bitcoin.
Bitcoin, on the other hand, is designed purely as money, and it’s highly optimized for this specific purpose. The protocol is grounded in common-sense economics with a supply permanently capped at 21 million coins, coupled with a security model that ensures this digital scarcity is credible. Any meaningful financial services, not the speculative frenzy of faux yields, will likely be built atop the most secure, decentralized digital cash with a genuinely fixed supply. This fixed supply, rooted in difficulty-adjusted proof-of-work tied to time, enables global economic consensus at the base layer in a truly neutral way. This is the critical economic utility of money that altcoins can not and will not ever be able to match.








0 Comments